Online JudgeProblem SetAuthorsOnline ContestsUser
Web Board
Home Page
F.A.Qs
Statistical Charts
Problems
Submit Problem
Online Status
Prob.ID:
Register
Update your info
Authors ranklist
Current Contest
Past Contests
Scheduled Contests
Award Contest
User ID:
Password:
  Register

Re:我来解释一下那些么明奇妙的WA

Posted by 2857 at 2012-01-30 21:22:20 on Problem 3295
In Reply To:我来解释一下那些么明奇妙的WA Posted by:gyarenas at 2011-11-21 15:20:38
> WA来自那些递归下降求解的代码.
> 第一种情况,使用|| 和 &&:
> 例如s为所给串
> int getval()
> {
> 	switch(s[c_s++])
> 	{
> 	case 'p': return (value & (1 << 0))? 1:0;
> 	case 'q': return (value & (1 << 1))? 1:0;
> 	case 'r': return (value & (1 << 2))? 1:0;
> 	case 's': return (value & (1 << 3))? 1:0;
> 	case 't': return (value & (1 << 4))? 1:0;
> 
> 	case 'K': return getval() && getval();
> 	case 'A': return getval() || getval();
> 	case 'N': return !getval();
> 	case 'C': return !getval() || getval();
> 	case 'E': return getval() == getval();
> 	}
> }
> 这种情况简单,大家知道短路求值吧,先对 ||左边的表达式求值,如果非0,则不会对右边的表达式求值,&&同理,如果左边为0,不会对右边求值,这样下标就不会按照事先设想的增加
> 第二种情况,使用&和|:
> int getval()
> {
> 	switch(s[c_s++])
> 	{
> 	case 'p': return (value & (1 << 0))? 1:0;
> 	case 'q': return (value & (1 << 1))? 1:0;
> 	case 'r': return (value & (1 << 2))? 1:0;
> 	case 's': return (value & (1 << 3))? 1:0;
> 	case 't': return (value & (1 << 4))? 1:0;
> 
> 	case 'K': return getval() & getval();
> 	case 'A': return getval() | getval();
> 	case 'N': return !getval();
> 	case 'C': return !getval() | getval();
> 	case 'E': return getval() == getval();
> 	}
> }
> 首先这段代码用G++会AC,C++会WA,说明此段代码依赖编译器,是未定义的代码
> 错误原因: C语言对表达式的求值顺序不是明确规定的,而G++是从左从左向右求值,C++则正好相反,比如: getval() | getval() G++先对左边的getval()求值,而C++则先对右边的getval()求值,也就会导致对s的访问顺序不会按预先的步骤进行,所以用G++会ac,C++会WA掉
> 正确的写法,去掉那些跟依赖求值顺序的代码(好习惯),分别求值,用两个临时变量保存,这样G++和C++都AC了:
> int getval()
> {       int temp1, temp2;
> 	switch(s[c_s++])
> 	{
> 	case 'p': return (value & (1 << 0))? 1:0;
> 	case 'q': return (value & (1 << 1))? 1:0;
> 	case 'r': return (value & (1 << 2))? 1:0;
> 	case 's': return (value & (1 << 3))? 1:0;
> 	case 't': return (value & (1 << 4))? 1:0;
> 
> 	case 'K': temp1 = getval(); temp2 = getval(); return temp1 & temp2;
> 	case 'A': temp1 = getval(); temp2 = getval(); return temp1 | temp2;
> 	case 'N': return !getval();
> 	case 'C': temp1  = !getval(); temp2 = getval(); return temp1 | temp2;
> 	case 'E': temp1 = getval(); temp2 = getval(); return temp1 == temp2;
> 	}
> }

Followed by:

Post your reply here:
User ID:
Password:
Title:

Content:

Home Page   Go Back  To top


All Rights Reserved 2003-2013 Ying Fuchen,Xu Pengcheng,Xie Di
Any problem, Please Contact Administrator